North Shore vs. South Shore: Where to Rent on Staten Island in 2025?

Staten Island, often dubbed "the forgotten borough", is anything but forgettable—especially if you’re looking for more space, quieter streets, and lower rent than what you’d find in the other four NYC boroughs. But when it comes to renting in Staten Island, one big decision shapes your experience: North Shore or South Shore? Let’s break down the key differences, pros and cons, and what kind of renter each area suits best in 2025.

🧭 Location & Vibe North Shore: Closer to the Action The North Shore includes neighborhoods like St. George, Tompkinsville, Stapleton, and Port Richmond. It’s the urban heart of Staten Island—more walkable, more diverse, and more connected to the rest of NYC thanks to the Staten Island Ferry. It has a city-like energy with a mix of old brownstones, newer rentals, and a growing art scene. You’re also seeing more development here thanks to its proximity to the ferry and ongoing revitalization projects like Empire Outlets and URBY. Perfect for: Commuters, artists, young professionals, people who like being “plugged in.” South Shore: Quiet, Residential, and Spacious South Shore covers areas like Tottenville, Great Kills, Annadale, and Eltingville. This part of Staten Island feels more suburban. Expect single-family homes, tree-lined streets, driveways, and a more laid-back, family-friendly environment. Public transit is less frequent, so having a car is almost a must. But in return, you get more space, quieter nights, and a tight-knit community feel. Perfect for: Families, remote workers, anyone looking for peace and space. 💸 Rental Prices In 2025, both shores are still significantly cheaper than Manhattan, Brooklyn, or even Queens. But there are differences: • North Shore Rentals • 1-bed: ~$1,800–$2,200 • 2-bed: ~$2,200–$2,700 • Studios are harder to find but can go as low as $1,600 • South Shore Rentals • 1-bed: ~$1,600–$2,000 • 2-bed: ~$2,000–$2,500 • Townhouses and duplexes are common here, especially for families Pro tip: South Shore often gives you more space for your money, while North Shore gives you accessibility. 🚉 Transportation • North Shore: Direct ferry access to Manhattan from St. George (25–30 mins), local Staten Island Railway, and multiple express bus routes. ✅ No car needed. • South Shore: Staten Island Railway runs through here, but travel to the ferry can take 45+ mins depending on how deep south you live. ✅ Better with a car. 🍽️ Lifestyle & Amenities • North Shore Highlights: • Staten Island Ferry Terminal (free ride to Manhattan!) • Empire Outlets & URBY community spaces • Hip bars, cafes, art studios popping up in Stapleton and Tompkinsville • Staten Island Museum, Snug Harbor Cultural Center • South Shore Highlights: • Great Kills Park, Blue Heron Nature Center, and access to beaches • Great schools and family-friendly events • Big box stores, strip malls, and parking galore • Quieter nightlife but stronger sense of community 🏡 Which One Is Right for You? Lifestyle Best Fit Daily commuter to Manhattan North Shore Remote worker or family South Shore No car, prefer transit North Shore Need driveway, space, quiet South Shore Enjoy walkable nightlife North Shore Prefer backyards and peace South Shore 🔍 Final Thoughts Whether you choose Staten Island’s North Shore or South Shore, you’re getting a slice of New York that’s more affordable and less chaotic—but with very different vibes. • Want urban energy with a side of convenience? Go North. • Prefer space, calm, and community? Head South. Either way, lowrent.nyc has got you covered with the best up-to-date listings, neighborhood insights, and rental tools to make the move stress-free.